Wednesday, December 19, 2007

The screen as a canvas: Youth Without Youth


A review of Youth Without Youth

The main reason for most people wanting to watch Youth Without Youth will probably be simple and indisputable. In three words, Francis Ford Coppola. When you think of the doyen of filmmaking, it is but natural that The Godfather trilogy, Coppola’s directorial masterpieces, will come to mind. But Youth Without Youth, which marks his return to directing after a hiatus of ten years, is a complete departure from the saga of the Corleone dynasty’s ascent and downfall in the Italian crime syndicate. Let’s get that straight. It is a film which is likely to draw extreme reactions. It is a film where one nagging thought will keep burrowing itself into the back of your mind as the film progresses: why did Francis Ford Coppola make a film like Youth Without Youth?

One look at Coppola’s perhaps not-so-varied filmmaking history may make things a bit clearer: his films were largely either based on books (The Rainmaker (1997), Dracula (1992), Gardens of Stone (1987), Rumble Fish (1983), The Outsiders (1983)) or they had a theme of aging or reincarnation in some form (Jack (1996), Peggy Sue Got Married (1986)), or, sometimes, both. Youth Without Youth falls in the last category: it is based on the book by Mircea Eliade and also stays faithful to the second thread of filmmaking that Coppola usually chooses to weave.

Septuagenarian professor Dominic Matei (Tim Roth) specializes in linguistics. He is struck by lightning one day and finds his youth miraculously restored, also giving him a highly developed intelligence. This piques the interest of Nazi scientists, forcing him to go into hiding under an alias where he chances upon his lost love Laura (Alexandra Maria Lara), who is reincarnated as Veronica, a young teacher. The pair retreat to an idyllic Mediterranean island, where Dominic tries to focus his efforts on his life’s work, a study into the origins of language itself. But he soon finds that he has to make a choice between successfully completing his research and permanently losing his love.

Youth Without Youth intermittently shows scenes shot upside-down, which lend an altogether unique perspective to the story, but it is questionable as to whether they are really necessary. It seems as if Coppola is trying to be a student again (he graduated from UCLA’s film school in 1967), and is simply indulging his interest in time and rebirth with this film. Granted, so many of his films were based on books - perhaps that limited his creativity - but this film was based on one too. It seems as if he really is just using the film as a platform for his thoughts, after so many years. Whether it is worthy of him, is doubtful.

Tuesday, December 11, 2007

The Rule of the Wild: No Country For Old Men


A review of No Country For Old Men

Move over Hannibal Lecter. Anton Chigurh is here. Without doubt, the most fear-inspiring character in recent times, No Country For Old Men is to a large extent overshadowed by Javier Bardem’s rendition of Anton Chigurh, the villain with psychopathic shades. Chigurh is not your average killer. His deadpan eyes, hulking screen presence and untraditional hairstyle are all part of a persona that seems intricately thought out. The way he walks - his unwavering steps intent on his aim of execution with the compressed-air cattle gun that he wields - all contribute to making you feel that you would not want to be caught anywhere within ten feet of this man. And that is Bardem’s achievement.

Llewelyn Moss (Josh Brolin) stumbles upon $2 million, some dead bodies and a considerable amount of heroin while he is out hunting in West Texas – clearly the scene of a deal gone wrong. He makes off with the money, and soon Chigurh is on his trail. On the other end, Sheriff Ed Tom Bell (Tommy Lee Jones, in a role that looks like it was written for him – which makes it a little less interesting for the lack of novelty), calmly sets upon Chigurh himself.

Based on Cormac McCarthy's novel of the same name, No Country For Old Men is less about this story though than about the art of film-making itself. The Coen brothers are clearly masters of the art of film-making – certain shots, such as the one where Chigurh and later Bell enter Moss’ empty trailer-cabin in his pursuit, sit down on the sofa in front of the switched-off TV and then look at the shadows that play on the screen say more than any dialogue. Not, of course, to say that the dialogue is not noteworthy – it very much is. Consider these lines by Carson Wells (Woody Harrelson), who is hired to track Chigurh down privately: ‘Just how dangerous is he?’ Wells: Compared to what? The bubonic plague?’ and you get a whiff of the sarcastic humor that plays throughout the film, entertaining you and scaring you ever so little at the same time. The Coen brothers have used the camera very carefully. There is the sense that each shot has been carefully planned, and visually it makes the story even more suspenseful, such as the scene where Bell stands outside the scene of the barred-off crime, holds the doorknob and looks through the blasted-off hole where the lock used to be. The shadows that play on the knob show us Chigurh hiding behind the door, and his realization that Bell is right outside – no words are needed, but the sense of the scene is conveyed brilliantly.

Tommy Lee Jones is all at once the perfect actor for the role of the Sheriff and the most predictable. The multiple wrinkles on his forehead tell of his character’s – and possibly his own - vast wisdom and experience. The more one thinks about it, the easier it is to understand that perhaps he was taken on for a reason. Sheriff Ed Tom Bell has seen all that he wants to in his career and is considering retiring because he feels ‘outmatched’. He cannot believe the extent of murder and mayhem that people go to for the sake of money. When his deputy asks him whether Moss has any idea of the kind of people that are hunting him down, Bell replies, ‘I don't know, he ought to. He's seen the same things I've seen, and it's certainly made an impression on me.’ Words spoken from experience, and as Tommy Lee Jones utters it, the truth of it hits you in the face with full force. As he reads a news item in the paper about a man running out wearing a dog collar when a house is held up, he says, sadly and honestly, that no one can make things like that up.

No Country For Old Men is a taut thriller that draws some notable performances from its cast, but more than anything it is worth watching because of its strength as a film – a complete product. The Coen brothers know what they’re doing. Let’s give them that.

Monday, December 3, 2007

Would a fight by any other name smell as sweet? : Fight Club


A review of Fight Club

When you watch a movie that’s based on a book and you haven’t read the book, you’re free to evaluate the movie in an unbiased manner. That’s what happened to me with Fight Club. The film is dark, literally and figuratively speaking, but director David Fincher knows what he is doing, and this film marks clear progress from his last, Se7en. A sense of gloom and otherworldliness pervades Fight Club throughout – you’re not here to laugh (if you do, then it will be out of shock or awe), and Fincher reminds you of that with every scene. The protagonists themselves are uniformly strange, yet compelling.

Edward Norton is a regular Joe office employee with one big problem – insomnia. One day, Norton (with no specific name in the film) meets Tyler Darden (Brad Pitt) on a flight. When he returns home that night, he finds his perfect apartment - and boring life - blasted into pieces by dynamite. Devoid of any belongings, he moves into Darden’s run-down house and needs very little encouragement to help start an underground fight club, where men battle it out one-on-one as a release from their mundane lives. The club soon becomes bigger than Norton likes, and as he races to somehow close it down before anarchy takes over the country, he discovers an unpleasant truth about himself.

Norton and Pitt nudge great performances out of each other. A film that moves at a steady pace till it socks you in the face in the end, Fight Club certainly makes engaging viewing. Go for it, or as Tyler Darden says, prove you're alive.